C
H
H
H
H
C Y
X
As soon as an asymmetrically
substituted ethane is recognized as a
structural fragment within an achiral
compound, the methylene protons of
this ethane fragment are always
chemically equivalent and always
magnetically non-equivalent.
Why achiral?
That‘s very simple. Within chiral compounds
the methylene protons are chemically non-
equivalent, which means, the question of
magnetic equivalence doesn‘t appear.
A
A`
X
X`
A final remark
The reality is more complex